As a garage owner or auto repair shop operator, your priority is often customer satisfaction. Offering a complimentary loaner car can seem like a generous and professional gesture—keeping your clients mobile while their vehicle is in the shop. But before you hand over the keys, it’s critical to understand the insurance implications and potential risks this service brings to your business.
Many business owners don’t realize that standard Garagekeepers and Garage Liability policies do not cover the exposure created by loaner vehicles. Failing to address this coverage gap can lead to serious financial and legal consequences.
Why Your Existing Garage Insurance Isn’t Enough
Your Garage Liability Insurance is designed to protect your business from claims of bodily injury or property damage that occur as a result of garage operations—think test drives or vehicles on the premises. Meanwhile, Garagekeepers Insurance covers damage to customers’ vehicles left in your care, custody, or control—typically while parked or being serviced.
However, when you offer a loaner vehicle, you are essentially operating a rental car business, which introduces an entirely new risk category. These vehicles are driven off your premises and under the care of someone who is not your employee. Neither Garage Liability nor Garagekeepers Insurance is designed to handle this type of exposure.
The Coverage You Actually Need
If you intend to offer loaner cars, you need to speak with your insurance agent about the following:
1. Auto Dealer or Rental Car Coverage
You’ll likely need a Business Auto Policy with rental/loaner endorsements, or even a separate Rental Car policy that is specifically structured to handle liability associated with vehicles temporarily given to customers.
2. Hired and Non-Owned Auto Insurance
If you’re renting or leasing vehicles to provide as loaners, this coverage is critical to protect your business in the event of an accident involving those vehicles.
The Risks of Going Without Proper Coverage
Handing out a loaner car without the appropriate insurance leaves your business open to:
-
Lawsuits and liability claims if the customer causes an accident.
-
Property damage costs not covered under your existing policy.
-
Reputational damage from disputes over who is responsible for damages.
-
Potential policy cancellation or non-renewal if your insurer discovers unreported risk exposure.
The bottom line? You could be personally liable for thousands—or even millions—of dollars.
A Smarter Alternative: Partnering with a Rental Car Company
Instead of offering loaner cars yourself, a safer and more strategic move is to partner with a local or national rental car agency. Here’s why:
✔️ Risk Transfer
The rental company carries the proper insurance and assumes liability for the vehicles and drivers.
✔️ Discounted Client Options
You can often negotiate a discounted rental rate for your customers, keeping the convenience without the risk.
✔️ Professional Fleet Management
Rental companies are experts in managing vehicle maintenance, driver qualifications, and accident response—taking these concerns off your plate.
Final Thoughts: Talk to Your Insurance Agent First
Before offering loaner vehicles to your customers, take the time to speak with your insurance agent. Ensure you understand your current coverage and what additional protections you need. Loaner vehicles are a high-risk offering without the right coverage in place.
Protect your business, your customers, and your peace of mind by making informed decisions—and when in doubt, team up with a rental car provider to take the worry out of the equation.
For a quote on your garage insurance, contact Insurance Incorporated at 877-428-8778.
We’re here to help keep your business running smoothly and safely—every step of the way.
